Q:

What are some arguments against utilitarianism?

A:

Quick Answer

There are a number of arguments against utilitarianism; many of these take issue with utilitarianism's seeming lack of concern with the principles of justice, promises and personal loyalty. Other criticisms focus on utilitarianism's apparent impracticality. Still, some detractors take issue with utilitarianism's tendency to lead one to distasteful moral decisions.

Continue Reading

Full Answer

One common argument against utilitarianism is that it does not assign inherent moral significance of justice. Utilitarianism is concerned with producing the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of persons. There are situations when just actions contribute to optimum happiness. However, it is also conceivable that in certain situations, a person or group of people are happier by doing that which is unjust. In such a case, utilitarianism seems to favor happiness over justice.

Another common argument against utilitarianism is that it is seemingly impractical as a governing philosophy for the general body of mankind. This is because utilitarianism is chiefly concerned with happiness, or pleasure. The problem is that human beings are extremely variable; individuals have their own conceptions of the pleasurable. Thus, creating a universal way of measuring happiness is problematic.

One of the biggest issues detractors have with utilitarianism is its basic premise that pleasure and utility are the determinants of worth. In Classical philosophy, things like virtue, knowledge, wisdom and temperance are good in and of themselves. In utilitarianism, they are only good if they have a demonstrable utility; otherwise, they may be discarded.

Learn more about Ethics

Related Questions

  • Q:

    What are the characteristics of an ethical organization?

    A:

    An ethical organization exhibits a number of key characteristics, such as honesty, integrity, accountability, respect, loyalty and concern. These characteristics must be exhibited by organizational leaders and trickle down to the organization's lowest-paid workers.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What are the pros and cons of animal rights?

    A:

    The primary arguments in favor of animal rights center around the protection of animals and prevention of pain. People against animal rights argue that full rights for animals would prevent humans from even using animals that are treated humanely. This often focuses on the ability to eat meat.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Why are ethics a concern in an academic environment?

    A:

    Ethics are a primary concern in an academic environment because academic dishonesty affects the integrity of the curriculum, instruction and overall reputation of the educational institution. Students are also faced with many ethical decisions while completing assignments, working with peers, and completing course tests and quizzes, and the result of ethical decisions can significantly impact their careers, progress and skill proficiency.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What are the most mentioned ethical concerns with stem cell research?

    A:

    A major ethical concern around stem cell research is the manner in which stem cells are harvested from oocytes and embryos. This debate centers around the idea of personhood and at which stage of life an embryo is considered to be a human, explains EuroStemCell.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore