Q:

What is the difference between concurring and dissenting opinion?

A:

Quick Answer

According to About.com. concurring opinions are written by associate court justices who agree with the majority opinion on a given case, but for somewhat different reasons than the rest of the majority. Dissenting opinions are written by justices who are not in the majority and wish to publicly disagree with the ruling of the court. In many instances, concurring opinions are actually dissenting opinions in disguise.

Continue Reading

Full Answer

About.com explains that the majority opinion is an explanation of the reasoning behind the majority decision of a supreme court. Even when a justice agrees with the majority decision, however, there will sometimes be more than one opinion issued in the case. Justices on the panel who disagree with the majority decision often write dissenting opinions that explain their reasons for opposing the ruling of the court. When a justice agrees with the verdict but begs to differ on the logic that led to it, a separate, concurring opinion may be written to explain a matter of law relevant to the case. Once the opinions have been written, the other judges on the panel are generally free to just sign their names to one or the other opinion as a way of endorsing either argument.

Learn more about Logic & Reasoning

Related Questions

  • Q:

    How many volts is an ATV battery?

    A:

    The majority of ATVs operate on a 12-volt battery architecture system (at rest). This is the traditional voltage system that is used by most vehicles within the United States.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Why did Hillary Clinton resign?

    A:

    The reasons for Hillary Clinton's resignation are largely speculative, but she is quoted as saying that she wanted to relax, according to Karen Lickteig from Mic. Lickteig claims that Clinton resigned to prepare for her 2016 presidential campaign, and quotes Bill Clinton advising his wife to get some rest and decide what she wants to do with the rest of her life when commenting about her potential run in 2016.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is subjective data?

    A:

    Subjective data, or subjective assessment data, is a common term in nursing; it refers to information collected via communicating with the patient. Such data, which is essentially the patient's own reason for seeking medical attention, allows doctors and nurses to gain an insight into the patient's physical condition and needs.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What does empiricism mean?

    A:

    Empiricism means to use an empirical method or practice and refers to the belief that empirical methods are the best way to achieve understanding in scientific or philosophical endeavors, according to Dictionary.com. Empirical methods are those that rely on experience or experiment. Empirical methods rely on observation alone, without regard to scientific theory.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore