As of 2015, TreadWright Claw mud tires receive positive ratings on Amazon.com. Of the 11 customer reviews, 82 percent give them 4.3 out of five stars. Reviewers note that the tires perform well and have a dependable, aggressive tread; reviewers also spoke well of the company’s customer service.
FourWheeler.com also gives the TreadWright Claw high ratings for performance, value, quality and efficiency. According to the site's product review, the well-balanced tires grab and eject muddy terrain efficiently and handle uneven ribbed terrain well, though they are somewhat noisy, emitting a high-pitched hum on the highway. FourWheeler.com noted that after road testing for a few thousand miles, the tires barely showed any wear or worn tread.