As of 2015, Milton Toyota received positive reviews on BirdEye.com and Cars.com. They received a rating of four out of five stars on the Bird Eye website based on 55 reviews, and received a rating of 4.9 out of five stars on the Cars website.
As of 2015, according to Cars.com, a 4.9 rating is based on 492 reviews. The Milton Martin Toyota website also features a variety of customer reviews, including a five star rating on DealerRater.com which claims: "Kimberly in the Service Center did an outstanding job coordinating the repair of two of our vehicles that were in for major servicing. Hats off also to the highly competent Mechanics that accomplished the repairs."