According to the ConsumerSearch website, the best light-truck tire based upon consumer reviews is the Cooper Discoverer A/T3, as of March 2014. This tire received a top ranking for its excellent daily performance and effectiveness as an off-road tire.
The next top-reviewed light-truck tires on ConsumerSearch, in order of ranking, are Michelin LTX M/S2 and Continental CrossContact LX20 EcoPlus. This ConsumerSearch website provides a general overview and a more detailed review of each tire, including an average price and where they may be purchased.
The 1010Tires website also lists the Cooper Discoverer as the top choice but states the S-T MAXX is the best choice for its tread design and durability.