As of April 2015, the headsets with the highest overall ratings are the Plantronics Voyager Legend, the Jawbone Era, the Motorola Whisper, the Jawbone Icon HD, and the Jabra Extreme2. The next five best headsets are the BlueAnt Q3, Plantronics Marque 2, Plantronics Discovery, Jabra Stone 3, and the Blue Parrot Xpressway II, according to Top Ten Reviews.
Tech Radar also rated the Plantronics Voyager in the top five (in the number two slot), praising the design for being both secure and comfortable. The noise-cancelling features and hands-free caller I.D also helped this device to secure one of the top spots.
The Jawbone Era was rated highly because it is not only small and secure, it also uses special sensors to detect vibrations in the wearer's skin. This means the device can differentiate between the user taking and any background noise, so call quality is greatly improved no matter how noisy the location.
Jabra maintained a number of devices in the top 10 on both sites with the Jabra Motion rated in the top spot by some reviewers,. This was mainly due to the long battery life and ease of use with a number of Bluetooth devices.