Track of the Wolf holds an average rating of 3.5 out of five stars on Yelp.com and 4.6 out of five stars on its Facebook page, as of 2015. These ratings indicate mostly positive reviews.
Most positive reviews of Track of the Wolf cite the availability and quality of its hard-to-find products such as muzzles, muzzle loaders and musket balls. However, response to the company's UPS Ground shipping times is mixed. One review mentions affordable shipping as a positive, but another remarks that the shipping for his order was astronomically high. Shipping quotes can be calculated on Track of the Wolf's official website, TrackoftheWolf.com.