As of December 2014, Christian's current theme song in World Wrestling Entertainment is "Just Close Your Eyes" as performed by Story of the Year. Christian previously used this song as an entrance theme from November 2004 to November 2005, but the old version was performed by Waterproof Blonde.
Aside from "Just Close Your Eyes", Christian has had seven other entrance themes during his wrestling career. While wrestling for Total Nonstop Action Wrestling from November 2005 to November 2008 he used "Take Over" by Dale Oliver. His six other themes were used during his time with WWE and all were written by longtime WWE composer Jim Johnston.