Why isn't fish considered meat?


Quick Answer

Reasons that fish isn't considered meat for the purpose of fasting include environmental differences and the intention behind fasting. There are differing opinions based on varying interpretations of religious texts.

Continue Reading

Full Answer

Although some vegetarians allow fish in their diet, the concept of allowing fish has religious roots. During Lent, Catholics are required to abstain from eating meat on Fridays, but many modern Catholic churches will hold fish fry events during Lent.

One possible reason for allowing Catholics to eat fish is because of a distinction that is made between land-locked animals, including birds, and water-dwelling creatures such as fish. Another possible reason, mentioned in the writings of Saint Thomas Aquinas, is that red meat was forbidden because it was "a great incentive to lust," a characteristic not possessed by fish. Finally, the idea that red meat came from animals that were farmed meant that abstaining from red meat involved making a sacrifice of one's property.

Learn more about Fish

Related Questions

  • Q:

    Do fish feel pain?

    A: Whether fish feel pain is a point of controversy among scientists, but the consensus is that fish may respond to pain but not in the conscious way that hum... Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is the meaning of a koi fish?

    A: Koi fish are symbols in both Japanese and Chinese culture and can represent traits of strength and of love. Their meaning varies depending on the color, sc... Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is cod's roe?

    A: Cod's roe refers to either the ripe egg mass in the ovaries of the fish or the fish eggs themselves. The adult female cod lays an average of four to six mi... Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What do tuna fish eat?

    A: The tuna fish generally eats smaller fish that range in size from 1.5 inches to 6 inches, although they will also eat crustaceans, crab larvae and squid fr... Full Answer >
    Filed Under: