One of the highest-rated coffee percolators as of 2015 is the Meyer Cookware 50124 Yosemite percolator, according to Amazon.com. The percolator has over 1,700 reviews with an average score of 4.5 stars out of five.
Another highly rated coffee percolator is the Dualit cordless, which scored higher than any other percolator tested by the people at Real Simple. The review stated that not having a cord was a big plus in the decision to score the percolator so high. Finally, one of the best coffee makers according to Cooking.com is a percolator manufactured by Cuisinart. The Cuisinart electric classic percolator scored four stars out of five and was the only percolator to make it on the list of highest-rated coffee makers.