The top reviewed 10-inch tortilla maker brands on Amazon.com are VillaWare and CucinaPro, as of 2015. VillaWare is the top-rated brand with 3.8 stars out of 5 stars, and Chef Pro was the lower-rated top brand with 3.3 stars out of 5 stars.
The VillaWare tortilla maker is the most expensive tortilla maker on Amazon.com and is $150 more than the CucinaPro 1443 tortilla maker. The CucinaPro 1443 has 3.6 stars out of 5 stars. When comparing these two choices, the VillaWare model features die-cast aluminum cooking plates, a non-stick cooking surface and 1,000 watts of power. The Cucina Pro 1443 also has non-stick aluminum cooking plates and features a ready light and wrap-around cord.
When looking at reviews for the VillaWare model, most consumers favor this tortilla maker, but some have found it to be difficult to operate. Some consumers also report that it does not cook evenly, and during the cooking process, the dough splits due to the pressure from the press. Reviewers also state that the tortillas do not get flat with this device.
The Cucina Pro 1443 reviews reflect similar complaints, especially complaints about not getting the dough thin enough. Other reviewers state that the dough sticks to the surface. Some people also report that this tortilla maker stopped working after a couple of months.