Simmons Beautyrest mattresses have generally positive reviews on Amazon, though some reviewers have left negative feedback. Many people say the Beautyrest mattresses are extremely comfortable and just soft enough for their liking without being too soft.
The majority of Amazon users found the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Plush Pillow Top to be to their liking; however, negative reviews made mention of the mattress sagging or becoming misshapen, in some cases less than a year after purchase.
The ratings from Sleep Like the Dead were a departure from those on Amazon, with the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge mattress line receiving a D+ for both owner satisfaction and longevity. However, the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge did receive an A rating for both availability and firmness options.