Reviews of Closetmaid products are generally positive with many products containing a large number of reviews. As of 2015, the company's most popular items receive four to 4.5 stars out of five on Amazon.com.
Two of Closetmaid's more popular items, the Cubeicals fabric drawer and Cubeicals nine-cube organizer, have four and 4.5 stars out of five, respectively. Both have over 1,000 reviews. Reviewers enjoy the modularity of these two products with the fabric drawer fitting perfectly into the nine-cube organizer but also being useful on its own. Multiple reviews noted how much users enjoy the wide range of available colors, allowing them to customize the look of the organizer.