Orange guard products receive both favorable and negative reviews on Amazon.com and Vitacost.com. Reviewers on Amazon.com give the product a score of 3.8 out of 5, while reviewers on Vitacost.com give a rating of 4.2 out of 5 as at November 2015. Positive reviews note the ability of the products to kill bugs without being toxic to inhabitants, while the negative reviews report that the product didn't kill on contact as touted by the advertisements.
According to positive reviews on Amazon.com, the products kill bugs on contact. Additionally, the users like the product because it is all-natural. Users also find the product useful for people who are sensitive to chemicals. Reviewers with kids in the house have found the product ideal. The citrus fragrance also appeals to many users.
On the negative side, a reviewer on Amazon.com says that the spray doesn't work unless the user sprays it directly on the bugs. Another reviewer reports that the product doesn't work on fleas. One person complains that the spray nozzle didn't work and that the spray ended up leaking all over his hand. A reviewer on Vitacost.com gives the product a rating of one out of five because it didn't kill the bugs but instead just slowed them down.