As of February 2015, customer reviews for the original My Pillow found through Amazon are mixed; 151 customers gave the highest rating and 71 gave the lowest rating out of 353 total reviews. Each customer has a different opinion on whether the pillow was worth the price or not.
The overall rating for the original My Pillow is 3.5 stars out of a possible 5. The original My Pillow sells on Amazon between $45 and $55. As of February 2015, the list price for this product is $139.99. Two common complaints in the customer reviews are that the pillow does not stay firm and that the information in the advertising is false.