Reviews for Maytag ranges vary by website and model number, but the entire line has a poor 1.3 of 5 stars rating on ConsumerAffairs.com, as of 2015. Some models do better, however, such as the Gemini model number MGT8820DS range, which has a 4.4 out of 5 rating at HomeDepot.com.
Consumer Search lists the Maytag MGC443BDW in its top five best reviewed list and states that users like the performance and value. Consumer Affairs reviews list temperature problems and steady repair bills as some of the most common problems. Many reviews on Amazon are mixed, such as the 2.6 of 5 stars review for the Gemini model MGT8885XS.