Karastan rugs typically receive very positive reviews. On Amazon.com, Overstock and Macy's websites, nearly all Karastan rugs with ratings have received an average of at least 4 out of 5 stars, and many have a rating of 5 stars as of October 2015.
Reviews for these rugs highlight their top-quality construction, softness and attractive designs. The rich, warm colors are a particular favorite. One of the few negatives reviews indicated that the image online was not representative of the actual product. Another stated that the product arrived damaged. However, there are very few of these negative reviews in comparison to the positive ones.