The Frigidaire FFFH17F2QW is the top-rated upright freezer tested by Reviewed.com and the second-best rated freezer at Top Ten Reviews. Consumer Search finds the Frigidaire FFU21F5HW to be the best upright freezer.
The Frigidaire FFFH17F2QW has a maximum score of 10 from Reviewed.com, which says that the freezer does everything right. When tested for hot spots, no two spots in the freezer deviated by more than 1 degree Fahrenheit. It found the defroster cycle creates periods of warmth but nothing high enough to degrade food quality.
The Frigidaire FFFH17F2QW has a size of 16.7 cubic feet, while the Frigidaire FFU21F5HW is larger at 20.5 cubic feet. Consumer Search recommends the 16.7-cubic-foot Kenmore Elite 28712 for consumers seeking smaller freezers.