The Whirlpool model WZF56R16DW and model WZF34X16DW upright freezers are the highest rated among HomeDepot.com and Lowes.com shoppers, respectively. The highest rated freezer at Sears.com is the Kenmore model 22742.
The Whirlpool models have 15.7-cubic foot capacity, use 466 kWh per year and are frost-free. Each comes with five door bins, three shelves and a bulk bin. The Kenmore has 16.6-cubic foot capacity, is Energy Star certified at 431 kWh per year and has auto-defrost. It comes with five door bins, four shelves and a bulk bin. All three feature bright LED interior lights and, as of 2015, sell for less than $600.