As of January 2016, the highest-rated Simplicity tractor on SimplicityMfg.com is the Legacy XL with 4.6 stars out of five, based on customer reviews. The highest-rated Simplicity tractor on BazaarVoice.com is the Regent Lawn Tractor with an average rating of 4.5 stars out of a possible five.
SimplicityMfg.com bases its average 4.6 star rating for the Legacy XL on 33 customer reviews, and 94 percent of the reviewers recommend the product. BazaarVoice.com bases its high average rating for the Regent on 76 customer reviews for various model years.
SimplicityMfg.com's second-highest-rated tractor is the Regent, and BazaarVoice.com's is the Regent EX.