As of August 2015, some good turkey roasting pans with lids are the Magnalite Classic 15" Oval Cast Aluminum Roaster, Precise Heat Multi-Baker/Roaster and Graniteware 18-inch Oval Roaster. All average at least 4.5 stars in retailers' online five-star rating systems.
At Wayfair's website, reviewers state that the Magnalite roaster is easy to clean, durable and versatile. The lid seals tightly. Reviews at Amazon.com say that the Precise Heat roaster is large enough for an impressive turkey. It is high quality and attractive enough to use as a serving dish. Positive comments at Kmart's site mention that Graniteware's roaster is a good value, sturdy and manufactured in the United States.