As of June 2015, Black Jack Asphalt Sealer has a five-star rating at Lowe's. At Home Depot's website, Ultra Shield Driveway Filler Sealer earns about 4 1/2 out of five stars. Henry Company E-Z Stir Driveway Asphalt Filler/Sealer receives four out of five stars on Amazon.com
The reviewer of Black Jack Sealer states that it is durable, high-quality and reasonably priced. Home Depot's most enthusiastic reviews mention that Ultra Shield is easy to use and spreads well. Negative reviews state that it is hard to mix and does not cover sufficiently. Amazon.com's reviewers say that E-Z Stir bonds well to the driveway and does not have a strong smell. However, it is priced higher than similar products.