According to CoffeeArea.org, some of the top-rated coffee makers by Consumer Reports in 2014 and 2015 are the Keurig K45 Elite, the Hamilton Beach two-way, the Cuisinart DCC-2600, the Bonavita BV1800 and the BUNN BXB Velocity. There are also other Cuisinart, BUNN and Keurig models with high ratings.
CoffeeArea.org lists 11 coffee makers with Consumer Reports ratings of four and above, and the Keurig K45 Elite with a rating of 4.6 comes in at the top. Keurig has two makers on the list, the K45 Elite and the B40 Home Machine. BUNN's four machines on the list are the BXB Velocity, BT Velocity, ST Velocity and the MCU Coffee Machine. Cuisinart's two machines on the list are the CHW-12 and DCC-2600.