Ashley electric fireplaces are well-reviewed by customers on Amazon, Wayfair and The Home Depot. The majority of customers on each of these sites rated their fireplace as 5 stars.
A customer on Wayfair says that assembly was easy and the wood used to construct the fireplace was of good quality. Another says the fireplace proved safe to use with their grandchildren.
A review on The Home Depot says that the fireplace "does a good job of heating the room." They say it has added value to their home.
One negative review on Amazon says that the color of the fireplace was not as described. They were expecting a black wash with brown, but received a solid black fireplace.