A good trivia question about Christmas could focus on how Boston banned celebrating the holiday from 1659 to 1681. The righteous Puritans prohibited gift exchanges, singing carols or use of decorations. Everyone who broke the law was fined five shillings.
Other trivia questions could focus on Christmas in popular culture. For example, how many gifts would there be total if you added all the gifts from the Twelve Days of Christmas? There are 364 gifts. In what year was the official birthday of Jesus declared to be December 25? This was decided by Pope Julius I in 350 A.D. There could even be a question about the origin of red, green and gold as Christmas colors. Green symbolizes life and rebirth, red symbolizes the blood of Christ and gold represents wealth and royalty.