Sixty-five percent of consumers recommended Amerimax Gutter Guards on The Roofery, with an average rating of 3.5 out of five, as of 2015. The Roofery rated the product number three out of six brands of gutter guards on the site based on these consumer reviews.
Consumers who were not satisfied with the Amerimax Gutter Guards complained that the product did not last more than a few months to a year before getting clogged with leaves. They also claimed that the guards only work some of the time and not on all areas of the roof. People who recommended the product liked the easy installation and the decrease in the amount of gutter cleaning required after installing the gutter guards.