How Rare Is a 1924 Silver Dollar?

As of 2014, a 1924 Peace silver dollar minted in Philadelphia is no more rare than the average Peace silver dollar, while those minted in San Francisco are considerably more rare than most Peace silver dollars. A mint condition 1924 silver dollar is more rare than one in poorer condition.

In 1924, the U.S. Mint produced 11.811 million Peace silver dollars at its Philadelphia facility but only 1.728 million in San Francisco. Based on its 2014 price guide, a perfect condition Philadelphia coin is worth $155, while a perfect coin from San Francisco, with the "S" mint mark, is valued at $9,200.