As of August 2015, there are positive reviews for Mastermind toys on Amazon.com. The best-reviewed Mastermind game is the standard version made by Pressman Toy, which has a 4.3 out of five star rating.
The Mastermind for Kids version of the game is the next best-reviewed version. It has a 4.2 out of five star rating. Consumers also favorably rate Advanced Mastermind, which has a four out of five star rating. The two other versions of the game, Travel Mastermind and Retro Mastermind, have slightly lower but still positive reviews. Travel Mastermind has a 3.6 out of five star rating, and Retro Mastermind has a three out of five star rating.