Q:

What makes a person mentally incompetent?

A:

Quick Answer

Cornell University Law School states that the term "competence" applies to an individual who is legally "capable of entering into a binding contract, transferring assets, or participating in a legal proceeding." According to LGCSC Legal, different states have their own assessment procedures that they use to determine an individuals' mental competence and capacity and which rights are able to be removed from an individual who is classified as mentally incompetent.

Continue Reading

Full Answer

According to Alec Buchanan, PhD MD, in his National Library of Medicine article "Mental capacity, legal competence and consent to treatment," when a patient refuses medical treatment, those wishes are required to be respected under U.K., U.S. and Canadian law unless the patient can be shown to be not legally competent.

Buchanan states that the mental capacity required for legal competence increases or decreases depending on the seriousness of what is at stake, and so legal competence is specific to the task at hand. Legal competence requires the mental capacities to "reason and deliberate, hold appropriate values and goals, appreciate one's circumstances, understand information one is given, and communicate a choice."

Buchanan explains that because laws recognize that mental capacity is a constant quality that can change over time and present to a greater or lesser extent, medical procedures that require consent over long periods of time often require repeated assessments to ensure that the legal mental capacity of a patient remains the same and that no legal rights are being withheld or mishandled.

Cornell University explains that there are legal standards through which those who are mentally ill can be forced to receive treatment against their will. Because involuntary commitment severely infringes on a person's right to be free from government restraint and the right to not be unnecessarily confined, statutes for involuntary commitment are subject to the due process clause of the 14th Amendment.

Learn more about Mental Health

Related Questions

  • Q:

    What is a homestead declaration form?

    A:

    A homestead declaration form is used to protect a person's home equity by providing that person with an exemption from standard liability so that part of the home's equity cannot be taken by creditors or in the bankruptcy process, according to Cornell University Law School. It is a part of the law that exists in all 50 states, but may vary slightly from state to state.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    Can a person cash an expired check?

    A:

    A bank has no obligation to cash a person's check that is over six months old, according to Cornell University Law School. The bank can choose to accept the check in good faith. In some cases, the bank might wish to speak with the person who wrote the check before accepting it.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is a civil injunction?

    A:

    A civil injunction is a court order that requires a person to do or stop doing a specific action, according to the Cornell University Law School. Some civil injunctions require that one individual not have contact with another, and these are referred to as "restraining orders."

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:
  • Q:

    What is an indemnity claim?

    A:

    A claim for indemnity is a request by a person or entity to be compensated for a loss or an injury, according to Cornell University Law School. The claim is based on a contract, typically with a third party, that is likely not directly responsible for the loss or injury.

    Full Answer >
    Filed Under:

Explore