Indy-Pic-A-Part is located at 940 West 16th Street, just west of the Aqueduct Street intersection and east of Fall Creek. The junkyard is most accessible from Interstate 65 and open daily from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., with the exception of Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's Day.
The store area contains thousands of junked cars and trucks arranged in rows and separated by manufacturer. The retailer boasts that its parts cost a fraction of those sold from dealerships and substantially less than other scrap yards. As of 2015, admission is $2.00 per person and customers are responsible for their own parts removal. While engine hoists and wheelbarrows are available for use, customers must bring their own tools, as Pic-A-Part does not provide them.