A majority of the reviews for Long Island MacArthur Airport on Google Reviews tend to be positive, with 49 reviewers leaving a 4.4 rating out of a possible 5, as of 2015. Seventy reviewers on Yelp gave the Islip, New York, airport a solid score of 4 out of 5.
Most reviewers that leave a rating of 5 out of 5 stars praise the airport for its cleanliness and its small and simple layout. These reviewers also tend to appreciate the distance away from New York City, with a prime location on Long Island. The reviewers that post a 2-star or less rating complain about the lack of dining options in this small airport, and its distance from New York City.