Brownies, cookies and other treats are the often the most convenient Super Bowl dessert ideas. During Super Bowl parties, people tend to come and go or congregate around the TV. This means that it is best to avoid sit-down desserts.
For football-themed cookies, bake cookies in the oval shape and use brown icing to decorate them to resemble actual footballs. Prepare brownies with green and white icing on top to look like the football field. Beer and pretzel caramels, deep fried candy bars, cheesecake brownies and peanut buttercup cookies are other good desserts to serve at a Super Bowl party.