As of 2014, Blue Bell ice cream comes in flavors such as milk chocolate, homemade vanilla, French vanilla, cherry vanilla, rocky road, mint chocolate chip, ultimate Neapolitan and strawberry. Flavors such as peaches & homemade vanilla and strawberries & homemade vanilla make fruit and cream flavor pairings. Blue Bell's The Great Divide combines rich chocolate and vanilla in the same container.
Some Blue Bell ice creams are based on popular desserts. These flavors include banana pudding, blueberry cheesecake and fudge divinity. The company has figured out a way to turn cake into ice cream with its birthday cake, Italian cream cake and red velvet cake flavors. An ice cream lover's holiday tradition may include enjoying a cheerful bowl of Christmas cookies ice cream featuring chocolate chip, cookie and sugar cane pieces with swirls of green icing. Alternatively, pink peppermint flavored ice cream fits in nicely with the holiday season.
People that enjoy nuts mixed into ice cream may be attracted to Blue Bell flavors such as butter pecan with roasted pecan halves. Green pistachio flavor has a liberal sprinkling of chopped, roasted almonds. There is also a black walnut flavor. Blue Bell also makes several unique flavors of ice cream including lemon bliss and magic cookie bar.