Cracker Barrel offered several special holiday pies for the 2013 and 2014 Thanksgiving seasons. As of August 2015, Cracker Barrel has not yet publicly announced whether it will continue to offer special holiday pies.
In 2014, Cracker Barrel's holiday pie choices included pumpkin, pecan, pumpkin pecan streusel, chocolate pecan, all-American apple pie and apple pecan streusel. In a news article dated Nov. 20, 2014, Cracker Barrel's executive chef, Bill Kintzler, predicted that the restaurant chain would sell about 600,000 whole pies during the 2014 holiday season.
Cracker Barrel has also offered a take-home holiday feast for six that featured oven-roasted turkey and dressing, sugar-cured baked ham, cranberry relish, three side vegetables and a choice of either made-from-scratch biscuits, sour dough bread or corn muffins.