Use a sample peer review to gain inspiration and ideas for critically examining a research work by a colleague or student. A peer review example or template offers ideas for questions to ask, what requirements should be met, how those requirements are met, and whether the cited sources are listed correctly and pertinent to the research topic. A peer review template also typically includes a section for analyzing the thesis.
Peer reviews often focus on structure and organization before moving on to more detailed elements of the research project. For example, a common question to use is, "Does the introduction preview the main points of the paper?" Other questions should address whether the organization and structure enhance the quality of the research and findings. Other questions should focus on clarity, flow and overall readability of the piece.
Use a sample peer review to discover the right questions to ask about proper citation and if the sources are relevant to the study. For example, "Are sources appropriately integrated and cited?" Questions may ask if the context of cited information is used in the proper context.
A sample peer review may also provide suggestions for closing questions or remarks. This may include a space for suggestions about how to improve the paper. Lastly, a peer review template should include an area for the student or researcher to respond to the comments and suggestions.