Using a Sheetz card when purchasing fuel at Sheetz entitles the customer to discounts on every gas purchase. The discounts are not available when a regular credit card, such as a MasterCard, is used alone.
As of 2015, Sheetz offers a My Sheetz Card which is free. Cardholders must register their account through the Sheetz website to enjoy the benefits of membership. When used in conjunction with any form of payment, the My Sheetz Card provides a 3 cent per-gallon discount.
Sheetz also offers the Sheetz Platinum Edition Visa. This is a Visa credit card that can be used anywhere. Cardholders are entitled to 5 cents off every gallon of Sheetz fuel. Customers can enjoy a total of 8 cents off per gallon when used with a My Sheetz Card.
Both cards offer membership perks when used inside the Sheetz store.