As of 2015, average ratings for Revlon ColorSilk hair color on Amazon.com are between four and five out of five stars, depending on the color reviewed. Customers cite the affordable price and long-lasting coverage as pros, although some reviewers complain of the color tone not coming out correctly.
As of November 2015, Revlon ColorSilk hair color has a 4.5 out of five star rating based on 281 reviews on Influenster.com, a product review aggregate website. It is the 52nd highest rated hair color product on the website. Many reviewers appreciate the product's ability to effectively cover gray hair, but some reviewers with dark hair say that the color didn't come out as well on their hair.