As of 2015, the InstaNatural eye gel sold on Amazon is the highest rated for dark circles and eye puffiness. The next highest rated on Amazon is the NuNutrients cucumber eye cream. Walmart offers the Neutrogena rapid dark circle repair eye cream and the Roc "Multi-correxion" eye cream.
The InstaNatural eye gel has no added fillers or harmful alcohol, parabens or sulfates, and it can be used on the cheeks and forehead to moisturize. This eye gel comes in a 1.7 fl oz tube. The NuNutrients eye cream works on reducing dark circles, reducing wrinkles and firming up the skin. It is safe for all skin-types and is made in a certified U.S. lab. This product comes in a .5 oz jar.
Walmart's Neutrogena product Rapid dark circle repair eye cream. The product description states that the cream "visibly reduces the look of dark circles in just one week," and that it "instantly wakes up fatigued eyes." This cream comes in a .13 fl oz bottle. The RoC "Multi-correxion" eye cream is a 5-in-1 product that not only helps with puffiness and under-eye circles, but also combats dryness, dull tone and wrinkles. It comes in a .5 fl oz bottle.