According to BeautyHows, the color eyeliner that looks best with brown eyes depends on the shade of brown. Brown eyes can range from hazel to dark brown to nearly black, and the specific hue will determine the best eyeliner shade.
Lighter brown eyes, according to BeautyHows, should strive for more subdued colors like dark brown eyes, darker shades.
Eyeliners that generally work best with brown eyes include: blue, navy, gray, green, purple and black. BeautyHows also advises that those with brown eyes avoid liners with pink, mauve and cool purple shades. This is due to the fact that these shades can make eyes appear puffy.