| Congress | |
|---|---|
| 33rd (1853–1855) | Columbia Lancaster |
| 34th (1855–1857) | James Patton Anderson |
| 35th (1857–1859) | Isaac Ingalls Stevens |
| 36th (1859–1861) | |
| 37th (1861–1863) | William H. Wallace |
| 38th (1863–1865) | George Edward Cole |
| 39th (1865–1867) | Arthur Armstrong Denny |
| 40th (1867–1869) | Alvan Flanders |
| 41st (1869–1871) | Selucius Garfielde |
| 42nd (1871–1873) | |
| 43rd (1873–1875) | Obadiah Benton McFadden |
| 44th (1875–1877) | Orange Jacobs |
| 45th (1877–1879) | |
| 46th (1879–1881) | Thomas Hurley Brents |
| 47th (1881–1883) | |
| 48th (1883–1885) | |
| 49th (1885–1887) | Charles Stewart Voorhees |
| 50th (1887–1889) | |
| 51st (1889-1891) | John B. Allen |