In 1999 Bogdonoff recommended moving the Tonga portfolio out of the bulging stock market bubble and into a pool of insurance backed investments called viatical contracts managed by Millennium Asset Management Company. In 2001 he learned that Herchell Hyatt, the owner of Millennium Asset Management Company, had stolen millions of Tonga's money and had filed false accounting statements for the Tonga account. Bogdonoff arranged a recovery program for Tonga backed by Lloyds of London to protect against the losses.
The Tongan government became paralyzed in an internal political debate lead by the Tongan Democracy movement in its effort to gain ground by embarrassing the Royal Family which dismissed the only senior government ministers who were attempting to implement the recovery plan to save the Tonga Trust Fund. Without the recovery plan the Tonga Trust Fund was effectively wiped out. The government proceeded to sue Bogdonoff and all the parties involved in the transaction for fraud and negligence.
Without admitting guilt of any fraud, Bogdonoff settled his part of the law suit with the Government of Tonga in 2004.