Leo Durocher was the show's first host, but bowing out after only two shows and was replaced by Mel Allen . Allen's lack of bowling knowledge made him an unpopular host . In April, Bud Palmer became the show's third host.
The show was retooled for the Fall of 1960. The show moved to Mondays at 10:30, Bayuk Cigars replaced Phillies cigars as the host, the Hollywood Legion Lanes replaced Wayne, New Jersey's T-Bowl as the show's venue, and Milton Berle took over as host.