Although the storm never made landfall, its large size and powerful winds produced high surf across the northern Leeward Islands, Bermuda and Eastern United States. The waves caused nine fatalities (eight in the United States and one in Canada) and moderate beach erosion.
Tropical Storm Gabrielle then moved westward at 17 mph (27 km/h) where it rapidly reached hurricane strength late on September 2, 625 miles (1006 km) west of the Cape Verde Islands.On the same day, Gabrielle's winds reached to 105 mph (169 km/h) as the storm was 1,200 miles (1,931 km) east of the Leeward Islands.By September 3, a ridge of high pressure formed a wedge between Gabrielle and Felix and on September 4, a trough extending from the Atlantic Canada southeastward to Florida caused Gabrielle to recurve northwestward, which had already reached category 4 status at that point.On September 5, hurricane hunter aircraft reported winds of at least 74 mph extending 100 miles (161 km) from the center and tropical storm force winds 250 miles (402 km) from the center as Gabrielle recurved west-northwest at 15 mph (24 km/h).
Hours later, another recon flight into Gabrielle reveled that the barometric pressure was slowly rising and the eye began to expand which is sign that the storm was slowly weakening. However, forecasters were unsure if the weakening was temporary or definite prompting one meteorologist to say that "Gabrielle may have reached its peak intensity, but its too early to tell"-to explain the uncertainty of Gabrielle’s strength and if the storm will strengthen even further.The concerns were addressed when Gabrielle reached a peak intensity of 145 mph (225 km/h) and a low barometric pressure of 939 millibars although the National Hurricane Center suggested the barometric pressure may have ranged from 935 to 944 millibars. The storm passed northeastward of the Leeward Islands and turned northward in response to a weakening in the ridge of high pressure caused by Hurricane Felix. Moving northward at 14 mph (23 km/h) , the winds of Gabrielle weakened as it bypassed Bermuda as a Category 2 hurricane.
Gabrielle then weakened to a Category 1 hurricane before it stalled 475 miles (764 km) southeast of Cape Cod, Massachusetts by September 10 as it interacted with a frontal trough extending north to south across the western Atlantic Ocean. Embedded in the jet stream, Gabrielle drifted slowly westward as it weakened to a tropical storm and recurved again to the east in response to an approaching cold front. Gabrielle then dissipated on September 12 and merged with a developing extratropical storm on September 13.
As Hurricane Gabrielle moved west-northwest, forecasters at the National Hurricane Center advised residents along the East Coast of the United States to monitor the storm because of its large size and strong swells it is producing. When Gabrielle, recurved northwestward, the National Hurricane Center forecast the outer edge of the hurricane to graze Bermuda, bringing tropical storm force winds and strong waves to the island.In Bermuda, cruise ships and other water craft were advised of rough seas and many residents rushed to stores to buy emergency supplies.
Numerous ships came in contact with Hurricane Gabrielle, two of the ships reported winds of 60 mph (97 km/h) and barometric pressures of 992 and 997 millibars. None of the ships reported any damage.
In New Hampshire, the United States Coast Guard rescued two surfers while looking for a swimmer who was reported missing earlier. Near Boston, Massachusetts, a 25 year old man was reported missing in the Ipswich River north of Cape Ann after a motorboat capsized in the rough surf. Two other occupants including an infant were rescued. In New York City, a 37 year old man was reported missing and presumed dead after his houseboat capsized in the heavy surf. Another houseboat also capsized, drowning a 58 year old woman. On shore, a large wave swept two fishermen into the sea, where they drowned. Overall, Hurricane Gabrielle left eight people dead. No damage estimate from Gabrielle’s impact on the United States exists.
Because the damage from Hurricane Gabrielle was minimal, the name was not retired by the World Meteorological Organization in their meeting in the spring of 1990 and as a result it was re-used in 1995, 2001, and 2007. It is currently on the list of names for the 2013 Atlantic hurricane season.