History

The New Zealand history of independent appeal courts addressing environmental matters began with the establishment of Appeal Boards under the Town and Country Planning Act 1953. The first planning appeals were heard in February 1955. The Appeal Boards were replaced by the Planning Tribunal following the passing of the Town and Country Planning Act 1977.

The present-day Environment Court replaced the Planning Tribunal as a result of the Resource Management Amendment Act 1996.

The Environment Court has a substantially larger role than the Planning Tribunal, with expanded functions and powers over planning, resource consents and enforcement. Virtually all important processes and decisions under the Resource Management Act 1991, such as regional policy statements, regional and district plans, resource consents and water conservation orders, may be reviewed in the Environment Court.

In particular, the Environment Court hears appeals on decisions on applications for resource consent on a 'de novo' basis. The Environment Court does not review the decision, it hears any evidence it requires and makes it's own decision which replaces that of the local authority. It focuses on "the merits and substance of the particular decision at issue, not the deliberative process of the executive authority that made the initial decision.

The Environment Court also has the power to make declarations that interpret what the law is under the Resource Management Act.

The Environment Court has the status and powers of a District Court so it can conduct prosecutions and enforcement of the Resource Management Act through civil or criminal proceedings.

The Environment Court also has functions under other statutes:

• Forests Act 1949 - Appeals about felling beech forests
• Local Government Act 1974 (New Zealand) - Objections to road stopping proposals.
• Public Works Act 1981 - Objections to the compulsory taking of land.
• Transit New Zealand Act 1989 - Objections regarding access to limited access roads.
• Crown Minerals Act 1991 - Administration of existing privileges.
• Electricity Act 1992 - Disputes about land access to existing works.
• Historic Places Act 1993 - Appeals about archaeological sites.
• Maori Commercial Aquaculture Claim Settlement Act 2004 - Appeals against allocation decisions of regional councils, and,
• Biosecurity Act 1993 - Appeals about regional pest strategies.

Decisions of the Environment Court may only be appealed to the High Court of New Zealand on a point of law.

References