are the best eleven U.S.
.
| Year
| Goalkeeper
| Defenders
| Forwards |
| 1970
| Bill Nuttall, Davis & Elkins College
| Buzz Demling, Michigan State University Al Harte, Quincy University Nick Iwanik, University of Illinois at Chicago Gerardo Pagnani, Eastern Illinois University Aladin Rodrigues, San Jose State University
| Al Henderson, Howard University Richard Parkinson, University of Akron Randy Smith, Buffalo State College Stan Startzell, University of Pennsylvania Al Trost, St. Louis University |
| 1971
| Cal Kern, Buffalo State College
| Alan Harte, Quincy University Gerardo Pagnani, Eastern Illinois University John Schneider, Quincy University Andy Smiles, Ohio University William Smyth, Davis & Elkins College
| Keith Aqui, Howard University Al Henderson, Howard University Richard Parkinson, University of Akron Mike Seerey, St. Louis University John Moore, SUNY Brockport |
| 1972
| Bob Rigby, East Stroudsburg University
| Chris Bahr, Penn State Gordon Cholmondeley, Philadelphia Textile Alan Harte, Quincy University Gerardo Pagnani, Eastern Illinois University Hans Wango, Davis & Elkins College
| Ian Bain, Howard University Eugene Durham, Philadelphia Textile Tom Kazembe, Wooster Chris Papagianis, Harvard Andy Rymarczuk, Penn State |
| 1973
| Frank Tusinski, University of Missouri-St. Louis
| Dave D'Errico, Hartwick Kip Jordan, Cornell Kevin Missey, University of Missouri-St. Louis Farrukh Quraishi, Oneonta College Ferdinand Treusacher, Brown
| Henry Abadi, Clemons Chris Bahr, Penn State Steve Baumann, University of Pennsylvania Dale Russell, Philadelphia University Tom Kazembe, Wooster |
| 1974
| Peter Mannos, Northern Illinois
| Jesse Cox, Loyola College Bruce Hudson, St. Louis University John Nusum, Philadelphia Textile Farrukh Quraishi, Oneonta College Mickey Rooney, Keene State College
| Chris Bahr, Penn State Frantz Innocent, University of Connecticut Tom Kazembe, Wooster Dale Russell, Philadelphia Textile Fred Pereira, Brown |
| 1975
| Peter Mannos, Northern Illinois University
| Sam Bick, Quincy University Nimrod Dreyfus, Adelphi Greg Makowski, SIU-E John Nusum, Philadelphia University Dale Rothe, University of Baltimore
| Carlos Merchan, Fairleigh Dickinson George Nanchoff, University of Akron Steve Ralbovsky, Brown Dale Russell, Philadelphia University Elson Seale, Philadelphia University |
| 1976
| Dragan Radovich, Saint Francis College
| Carl Christensen, University of Vermont Greg Gorleku, Eastern Illinois University Paul Hunter, University of Connecticut Greg Makowski, SIU-E Glenn Myernick, Hartwick College
| Andy Atuegbu, University of San Francisco Ty Keough, Saint Louis University George Nanchoff, University of Akron Louis Nanchoff, University of Akron Fred Pereira, Brown |
| 1977
| Dragan Radovich, Saint Francis College
| Greg Makowski, SIU-E John Nusum, Philadelphia Textile Adrian Brooks, Philadelphia Textile Herve Gulloid, SUNY Fredonia Billy Gazonas, Hartwick College
| Angelo DiBernardo, Indiana Emilio John, Quincy University Paul Milone, Princeton John Maciel, Western Illinois Rick Reice, Penn State |
| 1978
| Dragan Radovich, Saint Francis College
| George Gorleku, Eastern Illinois Adrian Brooks, Philadelphia Textile Greg Ryan, Southern Methodist Ty Keough, Saint Louis Barry Nix, Columbia
| Raymond Ford, UM (Baltimore) George Lesyw, Temple University Peter Notaro, Loyola (Maryland) Jim Stamatis, Penn State Ole Mikkelsen, UCLA |
| 1979
| Randy Phillips, Southern Methodist
| Saeid Baghvardani, Southern Methodist Mike Freitag, Indiana Barry Nix, Columbia Jerry Reardon, Adelphi John Young, Hartwick College
| Armando Betancourt, Indiana Steve Charles, Columbia Clyde O'Garro, Saint Francis College Ray Taylor, Western Illinois |
| 1980
| Randy Phillips, Southern Methodist
| Saeid Baghvardani, Southern Methodist Tim Gagan, Lock Haven Erhardt Kapp, Connecticut Joe Morrone, Jr., Connecticut Kevin Murphy, Rhode Island
| Trevor Adair, Lock Haven Hernan "Chico" Borja, NJIT Damien Kelly, Eastern Illinois Kemal Khilian, Southern Methodist Robert Meschbach, Indiana |
| 1981
| Skip Gilbert, Vermont
| Dan Canter, Penn State Richard Chinapoo, LIU-Brooklyn Tom Groar, SIU-E Tom McDonald, Philadelphia Textile Barry Nix, Columbia
| Armando Betancourt, Indiana Pedro DeBrito, Connecticut John Hayes, St. Louis Damien Kelly, Eastern Illinois Agyeman Prempeh, Eastern Illinois |
| 1982
| Skip Gilbert, Vermont
| Lou Karbeiner, Penn State Erik Nelson, San Francisco Adubarie Otorubio, Clemson Joe Ulrich, Duke
| Matthew English, University of Akron Tom Killeen, Philadelphia Textile Kevin Maher, Yale Steve MacLean, Philadelphia Textile Neil Ridgeway, BGSU Roy Wegerle, Southern Florida |
| Year
| Goalkeeper
| Defenders
| Midfielders
| Forwards |
| 1983
| Jamie Swanner, Clemson
| Mike Jeffries, Duke David Masur, Rutgers Simon Spelling, Akron Jose Vidol, Boston
| Michael Brady, American Aidon McClusky, Farleigh-Dickinson Neil Ridgway, BGSU
| Steve McLean, Philadelphia Textile Roy Wegerle, South Florida Tom Kain, Duke |
| 1984
| Jeff Duback, Yale
| Albert Adabe, Eastern Illinois Adubarie Otorubio, Clemson Shaun Pendleton, Akron
| Anthony Bono, Detroit Dale Ervine, UCLA Aidan McClusky, Farleigh-Dickinson
| John Gaffney, Virginia Tom Kain, Duke Michael King, Farleigh-Dickinson Sam Okpodu, NC State |
| 1985
| Tim Borer, Old Dominion
| Paul Caligiuri, UCLA Shaun Pendleton, Akron Michael Reynolds, George Mason
| John Kerr Jr., Duke Mark Mettrick, Hartwick Bruce Murray, Clemson
| Michael Brady, American Eric Eichmann, Clemson Tom Kain, Duke Sam Sumo, George Mason |
| 1986
| Jeff Duback, Yale
| Paul Caligiuri, UCLA Benjamin Okaroh, Boston U. Steve Trittschuh, SIU-Edwardsville
| Mark Francis, SMU Gary Furlong, Maryland John Harkes, Virginia
| John Catliff, Harvard Guy Furfaro, Philadelphia George Gelnovatch, Virginia John Kerr Jr., Duke |
| 1987
| Bob Willen, Virginia
| Seamus Purcell, Providence Paul Rutenis, Clemson David Smyth, UNC
| John Harkes, Virginia Mark Mettrick, Hartwick Tab Ramos, NC State
| Doug Allison, South Carolina Bruce Murray, Clemson Ken Snow, Indiana Peter Vermes, Rutgers |
| 1988
| Tony Meola, Virginia
| Jeff Agoos, Virginia Marcelo Balboa, San Diego State Kevin Grimes, SMU
| Henry Gutierrez, NC State Pat O'Kelly, Seton Hall Mark Santel, Saint Louis
| Scott Benedetti, Portland Brian Benedict, Duke Ken Snow, Indiana Joey Valenti, Duke |
| 1989
| Tony Meola, Virginia
| Kevin Grimes, SMU Cam Rast, Santa Clara Kevin Wylie, Vermont
| David Banks, Philadelphia Tim Martin, Fresno State Pat O'Kelly, Seton Hall
| Clark Brisson, South Carolina Peter Isaacs, Howard Robert Paterson, Evansville Ken Snow, Indiana |
| 1990
| Kasey Keller, Portland
| Jeff Agoos, Virginia Scott Cannon, Evansville Tom Loeber, South Carolina
| Dario Brose, NC State Chad Deering, Indiana Mark Santel, Saint Louis
| Steve Rammel, Rutgers Ken Snow, Indiana Billy Thompson, UCLA David Weir, Evansville |
| 1991
| Brad Friedel, UCLA
| Alexi Lalas, Rutgers Mike Lapper, UCLA Cam Rast, Santa Clara
| Peter DiMaggio, Columbia Graham Merryweather, Evansville Claudio Reyna, Virginia
| Gerell Elliott, Fresno State Henry Gutierrez, NC State Manny Lagos, Milwaukee Dante Washington, Radford |
| 1992
| Brad Friedel, UCLA
| Joe Addo, George Mason Scott Schweitzer, NC State Hector Zamora, Seton Hall
| Joe-Max Moore, UCLA Claudio Reyna, Virginia Joseph Thieman, Princeton
| Ben Crawley, Virginia Robert Martella, Bowling Green Alan Prampin, SMU Robert Ukrop, Davidson |
| 1993
| Tim Deck, Wisconsin
| Shane Batelle, Saint Louis Pedro Lopes, Rutgers Jorge Salcedo, UCLA
| Brian Kamler, Creighton Jason Kreis, Duke Claudio Reyna, Virginia
| Keith Defini, Creighton Jimmy Glenn, Clemson Brian McBride, Saint Louis Staale Soebye, San Francisco |
| 1994
| David Kramer, Fresno State
| Brandon Pollard, Virginia Eddie Pope, UNC
| Jason Kreis, Duke Brian Maisonneuve, Indiana Matt McKeon, Saint Louis Todd Yeagley, Indiana
| Brent Bennett, James Madison Mac Cozier, Charlotte Darren Eales, Brown Staale Soebye, San Francisco |
| 1995
| Chris Snitko, UCLA
| Scott Lamphear, Wisconsin Ian McIntyre, Hartwick Brandon Pollard, Virginia
| Ben Hickey, St. John's Jesse Marsch, Princeton Clint Mathis, South Carolina
| Mike Fisher, Virginia Matt McKeon, Saint Louis Toni Siikala, Campbell Andy Williams, Rhode Island |
| 1996
| Jon Busch, Charlotte
| Tahj Jakins, UCLA Pete Santora, Furman John Stratton, Air Force
| Mike Fisher, Virginia Steve Klein, Bowling Green Mike Mekelburg, USF
| Tony Kuhn, Vanderbilt Ignace Moleka, FIU Johnny Torres, Creighton Andy Williams, Rhode Island |
| 1997
| Matt Jordan, Clemson
| Leo Cullen, Maryland Kevin Daly, St. John's Pete Santora, Furman
| Daniel Hernandez, SMU Alen Kozic, FIU Ben Olsen, Virginia
| Wade Barrett, William & Mary Sigurdur Eyjolfsson, UNC-Goldsboro Dema Kovalenko, Indiana Johnny Torres, Creighton |
| 1998
| Adin Brown, William & Mary
| Matt Chulis, Virginia Jamie Clark, Stanford Kevin Kalish, Saint Louis
| Lazo Alavanja, Indiana Jay Heaps, Duke Wojtek Krakowiak, Clemson Maurizio Rocha, UConn
| Chris Albright, Virginia Seth George, UCLA Dema Kovalenko, Indiana Richard Mulrooney, Creighton |
| 1999
| Adin Brown, William & Mary
| Nick Garcia, Indiana Eric Denton, Santa Clara David Wright, Creighton
| Carl Bussey, SMU Daniel Alvarez, Furman Jeff DiMaria, Saint Louis Sasha Victorine, UCLA
| John Barry Nusum, Furman Mohammed Fahim, SMU Ricardo Villar, Penn State Aleksey Korol, Indiana |
| 2000
| Chris Hamblin, Boston College
| Chris Gbandi, UConn Cory Gibbs, Brown Ryan Suarez, San Jose State
| Carl Bussey, SMU Mark Lisi, Clemson Jorge Martínez, San Jose State Ryan Nelsen, Stanford
| Chris Carrieri, UNC Ali Curtis, Duke John Barry Nusum, Furman |
| 2001
| Byron Foss, SMU
| Chris Gbandi, UConn Danny Jackson, UNC Lee Morrison, Stanford
| Luchi Gonzalez, SMU Kyle Martino, Virginia Diego Walsh, SMU
| Nicholas McCreath, Rhode Island Pat Noonan, Indiana John Barry Nusum, Furman Dipsy Selolwane, Saint Louis |
| 2002
| Doug Warren, Clemson
| Todd Dunivant, Stanford John Swann, Indiana Chris Wingert, St. John's
| Ricardo Clark, Furman Sumed Ibrahim, Maryland Andres Murriagui, Loyola Marymount Diego Walsh, SMU
| Alecko Eskandarian, Virginia Pat Noonan, Indiana Tim Pierce, UCLA Mike Tranchilla, Creighton |
| 2003
| Will Hesmer, Wake Forest
| Leonard Griffin, UCLA Trevor McEachron, Old Dominion Chris Wingert, St. John's
| Scott Buete, Maryland Sumed Ibrahim, Maryland C.J. Klaas, Washington
| Adom Crew, Brown Ned Grabavoy, Indiana Vedad Ibisevic, Saint Louis Joseph Ngwenya, Coastal Carolina |
| 2004
| Christopher Sawyer, Notre Dame
| Ugo Ihemelu, SMU Drew Moor, Indiana Gonzalo Segares, VCU
| Michael Enfield, UCLA C.J. Klaas, Washington Sacha Kljestan, Seton Hall Danny O'Rourke, Indiana
| Justin Moose, Wake Forest Randi Patterson, UNC-G'boro Ryan Pore, Tulsa Jeff Rowland, New Mexico |
| 2005
| Chris Dunsheath, Bradley
| Greg Dalby, Notre Dame Tyson Wahl, California Marvell Wynne, UCLA
| Mehdi Ballouchy, Santa Clara Scott Jones, UNC-G'boro Yohann Mauger, Akron Brian Plotkin, Indiana
| Jason Garey, Maryland Ross McKenzie, Akron Jeff Rowland, New Mexico Willie Sims, Cal St-N'ridge |
| 2006
| Nick Noble, West Virginia
| Andrew Boyens, New Mexico Julius James, UConn Jay Needham, SMU John O'Reilly, Lehigh
| Greg Dalby, Notre Dame Maurice Edu, Maryland Ryan Maduro, Providence
| Omar Cummings, Cincinnati Charlie Davies, Boston College Edson Elcock, Old Dominion Joseph Lapira, Notre Dame |
| 2007
| Stefan Frei, California
| Eric Brunner, Ohio State Julius James, UConn Pat Phelan, Wake Forest
| Rueben Ayarna, Boston College Alejandro Bedova, Boston College Andrew Jacobson, California Peter Lowry, Santa Clara
| Xavier Balc, Ohio State Joseph Lapira, Notre Dame Patrick Nyarko, Virginia Tech O’Brian White, Connecticut |