Both Hebners received a $2,500 USD bonus for the match. In an interview with the WWF RAW Magazine in 2001, Dave claimed he suffered broken ribs as a result of the kicks Earl put to him as part of the angle, which kept him out of action until after WrestleMania IV. As a result, the storyline was shifted to have Earl come clean, and he was the referee when Randy Savage won the Tournament final at WrestleMania IV against Ted DiBiase for the WWF Championship.
After retiring as a referee following knee replacement surgery, Hebner became a WWF road agent. He worked as a Road Agent until July 2005.
Hebner was released from the WWF, renamed WWE, in July 2005 along with his brother Earl.
After being released, Hebner debuted in Total Nonstop Action Wrestling on the December 17, 2005 episode of TNA iMPACT!, appearing on the stage during a match between Team 3D and the Diamonds in the Rough.
In addition to appearing with TNA, Hebner opened his own professional wrestling promotion, the United Wrestling Federation (UWF), in Virginia. In addition to the promotion, he is also the promotion's storyline General Manager. In March 2006, the UWF announced that it had signed a deal to promote TNA-branded house shows in the Mid-Atlantic States, with the first shows being promoted in conjunction with NASCAR's April 2006 race in Martinsville, Virginia. UWF ceased co-promoting shows with TNA in early 2007, although the promotion continues to use TNA talent.