The Grandes écoles ("Graduate schools", literally in French "Grand Schools" or "Elite Schools") of France are higher education establishments outside the mainstream framework of the public universities system. Unlike French public universities which have an obligation to accept all candidates of the same region who hold a Baccalauréat in the same academic field, the selection criteria of Grandes écoles rests mainly on competitive written and oral exams, undertaken by students of dedicated preparatory classes. They do not have a large student body (3,000 at the largest establishment; most have a few hundred students each year) and are generally focused on a single subject area, mainly engineering, business or humanities.
Among Grandes écoles, École Polytechnique is considered most prestigious among Engineering Schools, whereas Hautes Études Commerciales (HEC Paris) is considered most prestigious among Business schools.
They have traditionally produced most of France's high ranking civil servants, politicians and executives as well as many scientists and philosophers, and play at the same level as the greatest American universities.
Classification as Grandes Écoles
Origins
After the French Revolution
The expression "Grandes écoles" came after the French revolution, in 1794 with the creation of the École Polytechnique by the mathematician Gaspard Monge and Lazare Carnot. In fact, the model was probably Mézières' military academy of which Gaspard Monge was an alumnus. It should be noted that some schools included in the category are older than the expression. For example the École des Ponts et Chaussées and the École d'Arts et Métiers were founded during the 18th century. Other prestigious schools such as the Hautes Études Commerciales (HEC Paris), the École Centrale des Arts et Manufactures (Centrale Paris), the Ecole Supérieure de Commerce de Paris (ESCP-EAP) and the École supérieure d'électricité (Supélec) were established during the 19th century.
Since then France has had a unique higher education system, where small and middle size specialized schools are totally cut off the university system yet fully integrated within the national education system. Some fields of study are nearly exclusive to one system, like engineering in the Grandes écoles, or medicine in universités.
Today
There is no standard definition nor official list of Grandes écoles. Legislation involving Grandes écoles generally uses the term "Classe Préparatoire aux Grandes Écoles". The term "Grandes écoles" is not employed in the Code of Education, with the exception of a quotation in the social statistics. It generally employs the expression of "Écoles supérieures" to indicate higher educational establishments which are not universities.
The Conférence des Grandes Écoles (Grandes Écoles Confederation) is a non-profit organization (under the French law 1901). It uses a rather broad definition of the concept of "Grandes écoles", not restricted to the school's selectivity or the prestige of the diploma. The list of the members of CGE does not draw up an official or even an "accepted" list of "Grandes écoles". For example some engineering school members of the CGE cannot deliver state recognized engineering degrees.
Methods of recruitment for the Grandes écoles
The methods of recruitment are the main difference between Grandes écoles and French universités. Public universities are forced by law to admit any student with the Baccalauréat and living within the university's area.
The methods of recruitment may be very different from one school to another. Certain schools are reserved for French citizens, while others have been so until recently. Here are the main three scenarios:
Preparatory classes to the Grandes écoles (CPGE)
Classes Préparatoires aux Grandes Écoles (CPGE) or Prépas literally Preparatory classes for the Grandes Écoles, sometimes nicknamed the "royal way," because it's the only way to get into the most prestigious schools.
The preparatory classes, either in literature, sciences or management (generally two or three years) is the traditional way to enter the most prestigious Grandes écoles. Most of them are in state high schools; there are a few private preparatory classes but they are expensive. Admission in preparatory classes are based on an academic report.
Many students register in more than one class to maximize their chance of admission. Some of these classes are very selective and successful at placing students into the top schools.
The workload is generally very high and in-class competition between students is encouraged. The classes are psychologically stressful, and some students give up before the completion of their studies. The goal of preparatory classes is to prepare the student to match the academic level expected to pass the competitive recruitment examination of the main Grandes écoles. If the student is not admitted to a Grande École, they are given the option of repeating the last year of preparatory classes and attempting the exam the following year.
Preparatory classes do not give any degrees, nor do universities officially credit preparatory subjects.
There are five main categories of Prépas:
- Mathématiques Supérieures, Mathematic and Scientific themed preparatory class. These prepare for the engineering schools and teach mathematics, physics, chemistry, and technology. They are broken down in sub-categories according to the emphasis of their dominants teaching.
- 1st year Mathématiques Supérieures; familiarly called Math Sup or Hypotaupe ; students are known as 1/2 ("un demi")
- 2nd year Mathématiques Spéciales ; familiarly called Math Spé or Taupe ; students are known as "3/2", or "5/2" if they are repeating second year.
There's a story behind those names: the most prestigious of the schools is nicknamed "X", entering a school is known as "integrating" it, thus if you integrate x between 0 and 1, it yields 1/2, between 1 & 2, 3/2 and between 2 & 3, it yields 5/2....
- Lettres humanities preparatory class, exclusively for the Écoles normales supérieures
- 1st year Lettres supérieures; familiarly called Hypokhâgne
- 2nd year Première supérieure; familiarly called Khâgne
- Prépa Economique et Commerciale mathematics and economics, . They prepare for the competitive entrance exams to the French business schools), and are broken down between Science (mathematics) and Economics tracks.
- 1st year Première Année; students familiarly known as bizuths
- 2nd year Deuxième Année; students familiarly known as carrés (literally: squared) (2nd year students who failed the exam and repeat for another year are known as cubes)
- Prépa Chartes humanities, with a stress on history and languages, known as Prépa Chartes from the name of the school : École Nationale des Chartes. The smallest prépa in number of students.
- Prépa Agro, biology, geology, physics, chemistry, and mathematics;
While most students in Taupes and Prépa HEC manage to get admission to a Grande École, there are fewer seats offered to khâgneux and chartistes and most of them will continue their studies within universities.
Recruitment at Baccalauréat level
Some schools are accessible after a competitive entrance exam directly after the Baccalauréat.
Many of these schools remain highly selective and prestigious, with most former students holding high-ranking positions in the public and private sectors. Often, students of these schools will go on and enter an administrative school, for which they are better prepared than the former university students.
Others include a two-year preparatory class directly in their program. These years of preparation are highly focused on the school program so students have higher chance to succeed in the admission exam or contest in their school, but really lower their chances to succeed in the contest for other schools.
Parallel admission
In many schools, there is also the possibility of “parallel admission” to Grandes écoles. Parallel admissions are open to university students or students from other schools. The Prépas years are not required to sit the entrance exams, provided that the candidates performed well in their previous studies. This method of recruitment is proving increasingly popular, with many students choosing to go first to university and then enroll in a Grande école.
Some Grandes écoles have dual diploma arrangement in which a student can switch establishments in the last year to receive diplomas from both establishments.
Categories
The Grandes écoles can be classified into several broad categories:
Écoles Normales Supérieures
These schools train
researchers,
professors and may also be a starting point for executive careers in the public administration or business. Many French
Nobel Prize or
Fields Medal laureates come from the
École normale supérieure in
Paris (
Rue d'Ulm). There are four ENS in total:
Their competitive entrance exams are considered to be extremely selective. They recruit mainly from Taupes, biology Prépas and Khâgnes, even though a small number of their students (less than 10 each year) are recruited separately on the basis of highly selective exams.
Until recently and unlike most of the other Grandes écoles, the Écoles normales supérieures (ENS) did not award any specific diplomas (students who had completed the curriculum they had agreed to with the office of the Dean upon arrival were simply entitled to be known as "ENS Alumni" or "Normaliens"), but they keep encouraging their students to obtain university diplomas in partner institutions whilst providing extra classes and support. Many ENS students obtain more than one university diploma.
The Normaliens, as the students of the several ENS are known, attain a high level of excellence in the various disciplines in which they are trained. Normaliens from France and other European Union countries are considered civil servants in training, and as such paid a monthly salary, in exchange for an agreement to serve France for 10 years, including those of their studies.
Grandes Écoles d'Ingénieurs (Engineering Schools)
Most famous Engineering Schools
There is a broad spectrum of engineering schools, many recruiting after scientific preparatory class. Things may be a bit confusing since many schools have a lengthy official name (often beginning with
École nationale supérieure or
École supérieure), a shortened name, an
acronym and, for the most famous, a nickname (and often a nickname for their students). Most of them are grouped in leagues, like
Centrale and Supélec,
ParisTech, Mines, the
Institut TELECOM (previously
Groupe des écoles des télécommunications, GET), the
Université de Technologie (UT) in most public universities in all regions of France, etc. Most of them are also joint graduate schools from several regional universities where they are located, sometimes in association with other international higher education networks. In no particular order:
- the École centrale Paris (ECP, or simply Centrale Paris) – part of Centrale;
- the École polytechnique (nicknamed X) – the military school part of the French Ministry of Defense, and a member of ParisTech;
- the École nationale supérieure des mines de Paris (ENSMP, or the Mines de Paris) – part of Mines, and a member of ParisTech;
- the École nationale des ponts et chaussées (ENPC, nicknamed the Ponts) – a member of ParisTech;
- the École nationale supérieure d'arts et métiers (ENSAM, or Arts et métiers) – formed by the Conservatoire National des Arts et Métiers (CNAM), and a member of ParisTech;
- the Institut des sciences et industries du vivant et de l'environnement (or AgroParisTech, nicknamed Agro) – part of the Pôle des sciences de la vie et environnementales et technologies de la région de Paris, and a member of ParisTech;
- the École supérieure de physique et de chimie industrielles de la ville de Paris (ISPCI) – formed by the city of Paris, and a member of ParisTech;
- the École nationale de la statistique et de l'administration économique (ENSAE) – formed by the Institut National de la Statistique et des Études Économique (INSEE), and a member of ParisTech;
- the École nationale supérieure de techniques avancées (ENSTA) – a member of ParisTech;
- the École Nationale Supérieure des Télécommunications (ENST, or TELECOM Paris, previously nicknamed SupTélécom) – part of Institut TELECOM, and member of ParisTech;
- the École Nationale Supérieure des Télécommunications de Bretagne (ENSTB, or TELECOM Bretagne), in Brest – formed by the University of Western Brittany (UBO) and Institut TELECOM – and in Rennes – formed by the University of Rennes 1, and Institut TELECOM;
- the Institut Eurécom (or just Eurécom) in Sophia Antipolis – formed now by Institut TELECOM (previously by SupTélécom Paris), with the École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL);
- the École supérieure d'électricité (ESE, nicknamed Supélec) in Paris, Gif-sur-Yvette, Rennes, and Metz;
- the École nationale supérieure de l'aéronautique et de l'espace (nicknamed Supaéro) in Toulouse;
- the Institut national des sciences appliquées (INSA) network representing the largest engineer training group in France and grouping the most famous grandes écoles of applied technology within regional universities: in Lyon, Rennes, Toulouse, Rouen, and Strasbourg.
- the Institut National des Telecommunications (INT), which changed name in 2008 and is now known as TELECOM & Management SudParis, member of Institut TELECOM
Grandes Écoles d'Ingénieur located in France (non-exhaustive list)
Grandes écoles with multiple specialization domains:
- "Centrale Graduate Schools": École centrale de Lille, École centrale de Lyon, École centrale de Marseille, École centrale de Nantes;
- the other "Écoles des Mines": the ENS des Mines de Saint-Étienne, ENS des Mines de Nancy, the Mines de Douai, the Mines de Nantes, the Mines d'Alès, the Mines d'Albi;
- the "Écoles Nationales Supérieures d'Ingénieurs" (ENSI), whose denomination encompasses about 40 engineering schools (including some listed below);
- the INSA group of écoles: INSA Lyon, INSA Rennes, INSA Rouen, INSA Strasbourg, INSA Toulouse;
- the Institut polytechnique de Grenoble: includes the Grenoble Institute of Technology, and the Grenoble INP (formerly INPG) which has six departments (ENSIMAG, ENSE3,PHELMA, ESISAR, Génie Industriel, Pagora).
Grandes écoles of physics:
Grandes écoles of information technology and telecommunications:
Grandes écoles of applied physics and technology or civil and industrial engeering:
Grandes écoles of biology and natural sciences:
Grandes Écoles de Commerce (Management Schools )
Most French business schools are semi-privately run, often by the regional
chambers of commerce.
The most prestigious and selective Management schools are the three "Parisiennes, located in the Paris Metropolitan area. There has been talk of merging the three schools in order to give them a higher international visibility. Other schools are found outside Paris, some highly selective, and sometimes compared to the three Parisians (such as EM-Lyon and EDHEC):
"Les Trois Parisiennes"
Located in/near Paris, these Écoles compete to admit the best candidates. The order below reflects the number of admissions from most competitive to slightly less competitive:
The best other schools (according to rankings)
Grandes Écoles without Preparatory Classes
Some schools are accessible after a competitive entrance exam directly after the Baccalauréat. They remain highly selective and extremely prestigious in French society, with most former students holding high-ranking positions in the public and private sectors. Often, students of these schools will go on and enter an administrative school, for which they are better prepared than the former university students.
These schools include (non-exhaustive list):
- the Institut d'Études Politiques de Paris (IEP). The most famous one, located in Paris, is called Sciences Po. Other IEPs are found in Aix-en-Provence, Bordeaux, Grenoble, Lille, Lyon, Rennes, Strasbourg, Bordeaux and Toulouse. They deliver a generalist program centred around political sciences, history, sociology and economics;
- the École du Louvre, for archaeology, history of art and anthropology;
- the École Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts, best-known as "les Beaux-Arts" (for fine arts);
- the École Nationale Supérieure d'Architecture de Versailles (ENSAV), for architecture;
- the Instituts Nationaux des Sciences Appliquées (INSA) in Lyon, Rennes, Rouen, Strasbourg, Toulouse, delivering diplôme d'ingénieur degrees in 5 years (including 2 preparatory years, the 3 remaining years are also accessible after selection for the best students graduating a first cycle university diploma, or from institutes of technology);
- the Institut Catholique des Arts et Métiers (ICAM) and École Catholique des Arts et Métiers (ECAM), offering a generalist program based on mechanics and electronics
- the École Supérieure des Sciences Commerciales d'Angers (ESSCA), best French business school without preparatory classes, delivers various master degrees in 5 years.
Administrative Schools
These schools train students for certain civil service and other public-sector positions. However, some students who undertake studies in these schools do end up working in the private sector.
All these schools are very selective. As an example, the most selective one is the École nationale du patrimoine, which enrolls about 1.5% of its candidates (who already hold a minimum of a master's degree). The ENA is certainly the most famous one, with a large cohort of its alumni joining the government and many having entered the cabinet. To join ENA or ENM, on top of their initial studies, most students follow a one year dedicated training course to succeed (IEJs - Instituts d'études judiciaires, see French law schools -, IEPs - Instituts d'Études Politiques see
Sciences Po - or dedicated programs). Most of these schools are reserved for French citizens.
Military Officer Academies
While
École Polytechnique, also known as
X is run by the
Ministry of Defence and its French students are reserve officers in training, it is no longer formally denominated as a
military academy. A small number of its students do however embrace a military career afterwards. A large proportion of its students end up working for the State's technical administrations.
Influence in French culture
Some
Grandes écoles are very prestigious, providing similar status to their graduates in France as
Oxbridge in the UK or the
Ivy League schools in the U.S, although of course their admission policies have differed. The top rated schools are truly elitist: the students of the top
Grandes écoles equal to around 1% of French higher education nationwide are accepted and fewer than 5,000 students graduate from them every year.
-This dozen of schools, which the French praise for being "généralistes", i.e., interdisciplinary, have traditionally produced most of France's high ranking civil servants, politicians and
executives and many scientists and philosophers.
See also
References
External links