Lieutenant-Colonel George Monro's British 35th Regiment of Foot, elements of the 60th Foot and militia troops resisted a long siege and bombardment by the French, but surrendered after parlaying with Montcalm. Though stubborn and reluctant to surrender, Monro eventually gave in after being shown an intercepted message from general Daniel Webb, the commander of British forces in the New York colony, which said that he would be unable to send reinforcements to relieve the beleaguered garrison. Thus, with little hope of relief, Monro agreed to Montcalm's terms, which allowed the British to leave with their weapons and be allowed to retreat without being attacked. After the British withdrawal, French-aligned Native Americans attacked and killed a few hundred of the 3,000 troops and civilians in the column leaving the fort. Historians note that it is likely that Montcalm tried to prevent the attack, but probably lacked the political means to stop it by force - even though he commanded 6,000 regulars and militia compared to 1,600 natives.
General Webb did, in fact, send reinforcements to Fort William Henry, which arrived one day too late, and Webb was recalled to England for his failures. In addition, the loss of Fort William Henry was a severe blow to British war strategy and would preclude any attempt towards Montreal for the remainder of the year. Thus, by 1758, three years of bitter campaigning by the British had granted them almost no territorial gains against New France.
After the battle, the Indians deserted the French and Montcalm was not able to follow up from his victory.
Montcalm attempted to negotiate an honorable surrender for the British troops. From a Native American perspective, the only way to surrender honorably was, to die quietly without a fight, or when in captivity, to sing a death song to please their captors. In fact, the concept of surrender was considered out of the question to most Algonquin and Iroquoian tribes, because it nearly always elicited great pain and delusion in the form of needless torture. The Chiefs of the multiple Native tribes got a rough understanding of the very European military peace terms but did not successfully translate the terms to their more than 1000 men of multiple languages. In knowing there was anger and confusion over their peace terms, Montcalm and his men elected to quietly march the submitted British to Fort Edward, the closest British Fort early one morning. When some Natives saw the troops marching out they let out a war cry, alerting all the Natives. A few Natives ran in to the men looking for a war prize.
Many of the Natives were expected to bring home captives to work as slaves, replace dead family members, or sell to the French as servants. Scalping was also a popular way of acquiring war prize. Scalping took time and was most often done on the dead, but because of the panic for prizes during this event, some scalped men alive. Of the 2,308 soldiers, 2,000 ran, escaped or were returned. Many of them were returned through negotiations with the French. In some cases, the government in New France freed Americans and British by purchasing them from the Natives.
After the battle, native warriors disinterred, scalped, and robbed many corpses from the fort cemetery. Many of these had died of smallpox, so these natives carried the dreaded "spotted sickness" to their villages in the Great Lakes. A devastating outbreak of smallpox soon followed.
Bellico, Russel P. (1995) Chronicles of Lake George: Journeys in War and Peace. Purple Mountain Press. ISBN 0-935796-62-2
Travel: Grand Tours; Where the Old World Made War on the New ; Great Writers and Their Literary Adventures. This Week, James Fenimore Cooper Goes on the Trail of the Mohicans
Feb 17, 2002; The author James Fenimore Cooper was born in Burlington, New Jersey, on 15 September 1789, but grew up in Cooperstown in New York...
DETAILS DETAIL JUST HOW ACCURATELY DOES 'LAST OF THE MOHICANS' DEPICT OUR ADIRONDACK HISTORY? HERE'S WHAT A PANEL OF EXPERTS HAS TO SAY.(Life & Leisure)
Oct 24, 1992; Byline: PAUL GRONDAHL Staff writer We asked the toughest critics we could find - historians and scholars who have made a career...