"Peter, Peter, Caviar Eater" is the first episode from the FOX animated series Family Guy for season 2. It is the eighth overall episode of Family Guy. It guest-stars Robin Leach as himself, and Fairuza Balk as Connie D'Amico. This episode's title is a reference to the nursery rhyme Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater. This episode originally aired on September 23, 1999 as the first episode to air on Thursday.
Lois' wealthy aunt Marguerite Pewterschmidt comes to visit, but drops dead on their doorstep (much to Peter's relief—"Be careful what you wish for, eh, Lois?"). A videotaped message from Aunt Marguerite informs Lois that she has inherited Cherrywood Manor in Newport, Rhode Island. Marguerite's video is based on Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous, and is narrated by Robin Leach. There, the Griffins receive a warm musical welcome (a parody of "I Think I'm Gonna Like it Here" from Annie) from the house's staff, who immediately leave afterward because according to one of the maids "The old bag only paid us up through the song." Peter hires them back after admitting that he secretly sold their former house in Quahog.
Naturally, Peter has trouble fitting in with the blueblood cluster after disgusting everyone with a story about a rat at the yacht club, while Stewie adapts immediately to ordering servants around, even commanding two to fight to the death, to music from the James Kirk and Spock duel from the Star Trek original series episode "Amok Time" for his amusement. Peter begs Brian to teach him how to be a gentleman. After several attempts through regular methods, Brian resorts to shock therapy. When Peter arrives at a ritzy auction that night, Lois is shocked to see him behaving himself and conversing easily with the upper crust crowd. Unfortunately, he also appears to believe himself fabulously wealthy, as he nonchalantly bids $100,000,000 for a vase. After Peter bids for the vase, he puts his pinkie finger in the same manner as Dr. Evil.
Lois demands that the family return to Quahog as soon as possible; she says that she now remembered why she left Newport: because it changed people in much the same way that her family is changing. Brian is only able to snap Peter out of his delusion by comparing him to Lando Calrissian and smashing one of his Star Wars collector's glasses. Brian borrows dialogue from The Empire Strikes Back to explain to Peter he's not really a millionaire. Although Peter returns to reality, he is still $100,000,000 short on covering his auction bid when Mr. Brandywire from the Historical Society comes to collect. When Peter is trying to prove that millions of dollars of history happened in the mansion, he points to a note on the wall dated 51BC that states "Jesus was here" (when asked about the BC part, Peter replies "Yeah, he's Jesus! He can do anything"), a large crack in the wall (which he pretends is where the Stock market crashed), a small toy train (which he pretends is part of Harriet Tubman's Underground Railroad), and even gets desperate by picking up a small rock (which he claims is where the pilgrims landed at Fraggle Rock). After these several futile attempts to "prove" that Cherrywood Manor has enough historical value to cover the bid, Peter makes up with Lois and finds a set of hidden photographs. The pictures show several prominent American figures (including Abraham Lincoln, Robert E. Lee, and Ulysses S. Grant) at Cherrywood Manor, which was a whorehouse at the time. Not only does the discovery make Cherrywood enormously valuable, but Peter sells one of the pictures to the tabloids to repurchase their old house double what they paid.
In the end Peter no longer cares what Lois's family thinks of him, since her ancestors were nothing more than a bunch of, "pimps and whores."
This episode was nominated for an Emmy Award for Outstanding Music and Lyrics for the song "This House is Freakin' Sweet". It did not win however. The second season also had Seth MacFarlane winning an Emmy for Best Voice Actor for Stewie Griffin.