This poem, composed within two years of Timrod's death, shows enormous restraint in a venue that could hardly have been more highly charged with emotion. Many critics have considered it one of his finest works, going so far as to call it his swan song. Some note the similarity between this poem and the English poet William Collins's poem, Ode Written in the Beginning of the Year 1746, which commemorates the British soldiers who fell in the War of the Austrian Succession. Timrod's painstaking rewriting of this poem shows in the differences between the early version, which is standard in anthologies, and revisions published in The Daily South Carolinian and the Charleston Mercury in June and July 1866. One might safely reason that the poet understood not only that his work would be tapped to help bear the burden of loss among ur-Confederate literati but that it would rise to a high station in American literature.